Jersey Mike's Subs operates one of the more straightforward online ordering platforms in the submarine sandwich space. Unlike some chains that require multiple steps or account creation before you can browse, Jersey Mike's lets you explore their menu and pricing structure right from their main website or mobile application. The ordering interface breaks down into distinct sections: menu selection, customization options, payment choices, and delivery or pickup scheduling.
Learn About Paying Your FGUA Bill Online →
When you first visit jerseymikes.com or open their mobile app, you'll encounter a location finder. This isn't optional—Jersey Mike's operates around 2,000 locations across the United States, and menu pricing, availability, and delivery radius vary significantly by store. A location in suburban Pennsylvania might have different weekend hours than one in downtown Miami. The system won't proceed until you've selected your specific restaurant, which ensures you're looking at accurate information for the store that will actually fulfill your order.
The online menu displays every sandwich Jersey Mike's offers, organized by category: Classic Italian, Famous Philly, Vegetarian, and Breakfast options (depending on your location's hours). Each item shows its base price, and you'll see price increases as you move from small to giant sizes. A small Classic Italian might cost $8.49, while the same sandwich in giant size could reach $12.99. This transparency matters because some chains hide pricing until checkout.
One practical detail: Jersey Mike's menu includes a "Mike's Way" designation on certain sandwiches, which means they come pre-configured with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil, oregano, and salt/pepper. You can order any sandwich "Mike's Way," even if it's not listed that way, by selecting those toppings during customization.
Takeaway: Start by selecting your location first—this single step ensures every price, item availability, and delivery option you see afterward matches what that specific store can actually provide.
Jersey Mike's menu structure rewards exploration because the customization system gives you genuine control over what arrives at your door. When you click on any sandwich, the interface expands to show the standard ingredients, then presents checkboxes or toggle buttons for modifications. You can remove items (say, the tomatoes from a sandwich), add extras (double meat for an additional charge), or substitute ingredients where the system permits.
Free Guide to Pay by Plate Illinois Billing →
The sandwich categories reflect Jersey Mike's positioning as a regional chain with East Coast roots. The "Famous Philly" section includes their signature Philly Cheesesteak, which comes with sliced steak, onions, peppers, and provolone—but you can modify the meat thickness, add jalapeños, substitute different cheeses, or request extra peppers. The "Classic Italian" options showcase traditional submarine sandwich construction with cold cuts, cheese, and vegetables. Notably, Jersey Mike's doesn't charge extra for most vegetable additions; you can load a sandwich with extra lettuce, tomatoes, and onions at no additional cost.
The size structure matters for value assessment. Jersey Mike's uses Small, Regular, Giant, and sometimes Party-size (for group orders). A Regular sub runs approximately 7-8 inches, while Giant reaches roughly 14-15 inches. Party-size sandwiches start at 3 feet and go up to 6 feet for very large orders. The price jump from Regular to Giant isn't double—it's roughly 40-60% more—which explains why groups sometimes order one Giant to share rather than multiple Regulars.
Sides and additions round out the menu beyond sandwiches: chips (brands vary by location), cookies, beverages, and sometimes salads. When ordering online, note that some locations offer limited sides compared to their in-store inventory. The app or website shows exactly what's available at your chosen location. Chip selections typically include Lay's varieties, Doritos, or Cheetos, with pricing around $1.50 to $2.50 per bag.
Takeaway: Use the customization checkboxes liberally—most vegetable modifications are free, so you can substantially personalize each sandwich without worrying about surprise charges beyond the base price and paid additions like extra meat.
Jersey Mike's online payment system accepts multiple approaches, which matters because different payment methods sometimes trigger different promotions or surcharges. The primary options include credit/debit cards (Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover), digital wallets like Apple Pay and Google Pay, and in some markets, payment through third-party delivery services if you're using those platforms instead of ordering direct through Jersey Mike's website or app.
Free Guide to Mold Removal Methods for Walls →
Understanding the pricing structure prevents checkout surprises. The sandwich prices displayed are before tax, which applies based on your delivery or pickup location. If you're ordering for delivery through Jersey Mike's own platform (rather than third-party services), you'll see a delivery fee—typically $3 to $5 depending on distance from the restaurant—plus a small service charge. These fees appear before you confirm payment, not hidden in fine print. A $35 order might show $35.00 for food, $3.50 for delivery, $1.50 for service fee, then tax gets calculated on the food total, resulting in a final charge around $42-43.
Third-party delivery platforms (DoorDash, Uber Eats, Grubhub) present different economics. These services charge Jersey Mike's commission fees, which sometimes get passed to customers through higher menu prices on those platforms compared to ordering directly. A sandwich that costs $9.49 on jerseymikes.com might appear as $10.49 on Grubhub. Additionally, third-party platforms charge their own delivery and service fees, often reaching $5-8 total, which can make the final bill considerably higher. Many Jersey Mike's locations actively encourage direct ordering by highlighting that option prominently.
Payment processing happens immediately upon order submission. The charge appears on your card right away, not when the order is picked up or delivered. If you need to cancel, you typically have a short window (usually 10-15 minutes, though this varies by location) before the order goes to the kitchen. After that point, Jersey Mike's policy generally doesn't refund cancelled orders, though you can contact the specific location to discuss circumstances.
Takeaway: Ordering directly through jerseymikes.com or their app typically results in lower total costs than using third-party delivery services, since you avoid the markup those platforms apply to menu prices.
Jersey Mike's online system requires you to choose between delivery and pickup before finalizing your order, and this choice significantly affects your timeline and total cost. The pickup option involves driving to your selected restaurant location and retrieving your order from a designated area—usually a pickup counter or window. Pickup orders are typically ready within 15-25 minutes of submission, depending on the location's current volume and complexity of your order (a custom sandwich takes slightly longer than a standard one). You'll receive an estimated ready time when you submit the order, and many locations send a notification when your order is ready for pickup.
How to Delete Your Fitbit Account Guide →
Delivery through Jersey Mike's own system reaches different distances based on location. Urban Jersey Mike's locations might deliver within a 2-3 mile radius, while suburban or rural locations could serve a 5-7 mile area. The app's map feature shows your delivery zone—if your address falls within it, delivery becomes an option; if not, you can only pickup. Delivery times typically run 30-50 minutes from order submission, though peak hours (lunch rush 11 AM-2 PM, dinner 5-8 PM) can extend this to 60 minutes. Weekend deliveries sometimes move slower due to driver volume constraints.
The financial comparison between pickup and delivery shapes many ordering decisions. Pickup costs nothing beyond your food and tax. Delivery adds that $3-5 delivery fee plus service charge, plus potentially a tip (many customers add 15-20% tips for delivery). So a $15 food order becomes roughly $20-22 with all fees and tip included. That's roughly a 40% increase over pickup cost. For budget-conscious orders, pickup represents substantial savings.
Practical considerations affect this choice beyond just cost. Weather, vehicle availability, time constraints, and order size all matter. A giant sandwich that you're splitting among three people might make sense for delivery if it's raining. A smaller individual order might make more sense for pickup if you're already driving past the location. Jersey Mike's location finder shows
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.