Small potatoes—varieties like fingerlings, new potatoes, and baby reds—occupy a unique space in cooking. Unlike their larger cousins, which often require peeling, cutting, and extended cooking times, small potatoes can be prepared whole, skin intact, in a fraction of the time. This isn't just a convenience factor; it's a genuine difference in how these vegetables behave during cooking.
Learn About Paying Your FGUA Bill Online →
The skin on small potatoes contains much of their nutritional value, including fiber and important minerals like potassium and manganese. When you work with small potatoes intentionally—understanding their size, structure, and cooking properties—you preserve these nutrients while creating better texture in your final dish. A properly prepared small potato holds together during boiling or roasting instead of falling apart or becoming mushy.
Small potatoes also cook more evenly than large ones. Because heat penetrates throughout a smaller vegetable more quickly and uniformly, you avoid the common problem of having a cooked exterior with an undercooked center, or vice versa. This matters whether you're making potato salad, a side dish, or adding potatoes to a stew.
Many home cooks actually overcomplicate small potato preparation, treating them like full-size russets when they don't need the same treatment. Understanding the specific characteristics of small potatoes—their thin skins, dense starch content, and quick-cooking nature—changes how you approach them in the kitchen. This guide focuses on techniques that work with these characteristics rather than against them.
Practical takeaway: Small potatoes are fundamentally different from large potatoes and benefit from preparation methods that respect their size and structure. Keeping the skin on is often the right choice, not an oversight.
Before you do anything with small potatoes, you need to choose the right ones for your intended use. Not all small potatoes are identical, and selection affects how you'll prepare them. Fingerling potatoes are longer and thinner, with a waxy texture that holds shape well during cooking. New potatoes—which are simply immature potatoes of standard varieties harvested early—have thinner, more delicate skin and a creamier texture. Baby potatoes marketed in grocery stores are often selected for uniform size within a batch, which helps with even cooking.
Free Guide to Pay by Plate Illinois Billing →
When examining small potatoes at the market, look for ones that feel firm and heavy for their size. Avoid any with soft spots, sprouting eyes that are more than tiny buds, or green tinted areas (which indicate solanine, a potentially harmful alkaloid). The skin should be relatively smooth without deep pits or damage. Size uniformity within your batch matters significantly—if you're cooking a pound of small potatoes together, you want them roughly the same size so they finish cooking at the same time.
Check the age of the potatoes if available. New potatoes are genuinely thin-skinned and delicate, while mature small potatoes have firmer skin. This affects your washing technique and how aggressively you can handle them. A fingerling potato can withstand more vigorous scrubbing than a fragile new potato fresh from spring harvest.
Storage matters before you cook, too. Small potatoes should be kept in a cool, dark place—not in direct light and not in the refrigerator (cold temperatures convert their starches to sugars, affecting flavor and texture). A pantry or dark cupboard works well. Use them within a week or two for best quality, though properly stored small potatoes can last several weeks.
Practical takeaway: Choose small potatoes that feel firm, have unblemished skin, and are relatively uniform in size. Understanding the specific variety you're working with helps you adjust your preparation method appropriately.
Washing small potatoes is straightforward but requires a gentle approach, especially with new potatoes whose thin skin can bruise or peel away with rough handling. Start with cool running water—not hot, which can soften the skin unnecessarily. Place the potatoes in a colander and rinse them under the running water while using your hands to gently rub the surface, working around any dirt or soil clinging to them.
Free Guide to Mold Removal Methods for Walls →
For visibly dirty potatoes, a soft vegetable brush works well. The key word is soft—you're not scrubbing aggressively but rather removing caked-on soil and loosening any dirt that's stuck in surface crevices. Work in gentle circular motions, paying special attention to areas where the soil has settled into small depressions. If you don't have a vegetable brush, a clean cloth or sponge works adequately.
Potatoes grown in clay-heavy soil may need a soak before brushing. Place them in a bowl of cool water for 5-10 minutes to soften the dried soil, which comes off much more easily after soaking. For potatoes that are only lightly dusty, the soak may not be necessary—running water and a gentle rub often suffices.
Pay attention to the potato's eyes (small indentations where sprouts emerge). Dirt and soil can accumulate here. A soft brush or the corner of a cloth can dislodge this without damaging the surrounding skin. Once the potatoes look clean, drain them well in the colander and pat them dry with a clean cloth or paper towel. Excess moisture on the surface can interfere with browning if you're roasting, or can dilute flavors in boiled preparations.
The entire washing process for a pound of small potatoes should take only 2-3 minutes. You're not aiming for surgical cleanliness—small amounts of skin and natural earth are fine and contribute to rustic texture. The goal is removing loose soil so you can cook them as-is without grit.
Practical takeaway: Gentle washing with soft tools and cool water preserves the skin integrity while removing surface dirt. Dry thoroughly after washing, especially if you plan to roast the potatoes.
Whether you cut small potatoes depends entirely on your cooking method and how you plan to serve them. For many preparations—boiling for potato salad, roasting as a side dish, or adding to stews—leaving small potatoes whole is the right choice. Whole potatoes retain more nutrients and flavor since they're not exposing as much surface area to water or heat.
How to Delete Your Fitbit Account Guide →
However, certain situations call for cutting. If your small potatoes are genuinely tiny (roughly pea-sized or smaller), leaving them whole can make them hard to eat with a fork. Cutting them in half makes them easier to consume. For fingerling potatoes, which are naturally longer, you might halve them lengthwise to create a flat surface, which is particularly useful when roasting—the flat side makes contact with the hot pan and develops browning.
If you need to remove any blemishes, sprouts, or bruised areas, do this after washing but before cooking. A paring knife removes sprouting eyes quickly—just turn the knife at a slight angle and make a small circular cut around the eye. For small dark spots or minor blemishes, a light scrape with the knife blade or a quick peel with a vegetable peeler removes the damaged area while preserving the rest of the skin.
For boiling applications (potato salad, mashing), keep potatoes whole if they're truly small (under 1.5 inches), or halve them if larger. For roasting, halving or leaving whole both work, depending on how you want them to look on the plate. Whole roasted baby potatoes look more elegant; halved potatoes brown more efficiently on their flat surface.
For soups and stews, cut small potatoes in half or quarters depending on the other ingredients. They should be slightly smaller than large vegetable chunks around them so they finish cooking simultaneously. If you're adding them to a slow-cooker stew that simmers for hours, cutting them into smaller pieces prevents them from becoming mushy while the surrounding ingredients finish cooking.
A practical note: cut potatoes just before cooking if possible. Once cut, the exposed starch oxidizes and the potato begins losing nutrients. If you must cut in advance, place cut potatoes in cool water to prevent browning, but plan to cook them within an hour.
Practical takeaway: Most small potatoes don
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.