Learn About Social Security Appeal Options and Process

Overview of Social Security Appeals

When Social Security denies a claim or makes a decision someone disagrees with, the person has the right to challenge that decision. This process is called an appeal. Social Security tracks data on appeals, and according to their annual statistics, hundreds of thousands of people file appeals each year. In fiscal year 2023, the Social Security Administration received over 600,000 appeal requests across all levels of review.

Get Your Free Guide to Aviator Mastercard Online Account Management →

Understanding the appeal process matters because many initial decisions get overturned at later stages. Social Security data shows that roughly 35 to 40 percent of cases that reach a hearing before an administrative law judge result in a favorable decision for the claimant. This means that people who take the step to appeal their denial have a meaningful opportunity to change the outcome.

The appeal process has different levels, and each one follows specific rules and timelines. A person does not have to accept Social Security's first decision. Instead, they can move through several review stages, each designed to give their case fresh consideration. The process can take time—sometimes several years—but it provides multiple opportunities to present information and challenge decisions.

Social Security handles appeals for several types of decisions, including denials of retirement benefits, disability benefits, supplemental security income (SSI), and Medicare determinations. The rules and procedures are similar across these programs, though some details may differ.

Practical Takeaway: Knowing that appeals exist and understanding their general structure is the first step. Many people do not realize they can challenge a Social Security decision, so simply learning that multiple review options are available can help someone decide whether to pursue further action.

The Four Levels of Appeal

Social Security's appeal system has four distinct stages: reconsideration, hearing before an administrative law judge (ALJ), Appeals Council review, and federal court review. Each level represents a chance to present the case again or have someone new examine the decision.

Get Your Free Thermostat Settings Guide →

The first level is called reconsideration. At this stage, a different examiner at Social Security looks at the case from the beginning. This person reviews the original file and any new information the person submits. The reconsideration process typically takes 60 to 90 days, though it can take longer in some cases. According to Social Security statistics, roughly 10 to 15 percent of reconsideration requests result in a favorable decision, meaning the original denial gets reversed.

If reconsideration results in an unfavorable decision, the person can request a hearing before an administrative law judge. This is the second level of appeal. At a hearing, the person can present their case in person (or by video or phone), have a witness or representative present, and hear evidence presented by Social Security. An administrative law judge is an independent decision-maker who does not work for the same part of Social Security that made the original decision. Hearing decisions have a much higher favorable outcome rate—approximately 35 to 40 percent of hearings result in a decision in the claimant's favor.

The third level is Appeals Council review. If the administrative law judge denies the case, the person can ask the Appeals Council to examine the decision. The Appeals Council is a group within Social Security that reviews hearing decisions. Most Appeals Council requests do not result in a reversal—fewer than 5 percent of Appeals Council cases are decided in the claimant's favor. However, the Appeals Council can send cases back to a judge for further review if it finds an error.

Federal court review is the fourth and final level. If the Appeals Council denies the request or if the person wishes to challenge an Appeals Council decision, they can file a case in federal district court. Federal court review is rare and typically requires the help of an attorney. The person must demonstrate that Social Security's decision was not supported by substantial evidence in the record.

Practical Takeaway: Understanding that four levels exist helps someone know whether they have options remaining. Each level offers a different type of review, so a person should not assume that one unfavorable decision closes all doors.

Reconsideration: The First Appeal Level

Reconsideration is the first formal appeal option after an initial Social Security decision. To request reconsideration, a person must file within 60 days of receiving the original decision letter. Social Security may extend this deadline by up to 10 additional days if the person has a good reason for missing the 60-day window, such as serious illness or receiving the notice late.

Your Free Credit Card Sign In Guide →

During reconsideration, Social Security assigns a new examiner to the case. This examiner has access to the entire file from the initial decision, plus any new medical records, statements, or other documentation the person submits. The examiner does not meet with the person—the review happens through documents only. This is a significant difference from a hearing, where the person can testify and present their case in person.

To strengthen a reconsideration request, a person should submit new evidence when possible. Examples include recent medical test results, updated treatment records, statements from doctors, or documentation of work attempts. Social Security may reconsider even without new evidence if the examiner finds an error in the original decision, but new evidence can make a stronger case.

The reconsideration process typically takes 60 to 90 days, though wait times vary by location and complexity of the case. During this time, the person typically does not receive monthly benefits, unless they are already receiving benefits for a different reason.

According to Social Security's own data, reconsideration results in a favorable decision roughly 10 to 15 percent of the time. While this percentage is relatively low compared to hearings, reconsideration serves an important function: it catches errors quickly and can resolve some cases without the need for a longer hearing process. Additionally, reconsideration is the only appeal level that happens entirely through document review, making it more accessible for people who cannot attend in-person meetings.

To request reconsideration, a person should contact their local Social Security office, call Social Security's main number (1-800-772-1213), or visit Social Security's website. They will need to provide their Social Security number and information about the decision they want to appeal.

Practical Takeaway: Reconsideration is a relatively quick first step that gives a person 60 days to act. Gathering any new medical or other supporting evidence before filing increases the chances of a favorable outcome at this stage.

Hearing Before an Administrative Law Judge

If reconsideration results in an unfavorable decision, a person can request a hearing before an administrative law judge (ALJ). This is the second level of appeal and often the most important stage. An ALJ hearing is different from reconsideration because the person can appear in person, present testimony, question evidence, and have a witness or representative present. According to Social Security data, approximately 35 to 40 percent of cases that go to hearing result in a favorable decision for the claimant.

Get Your Free Guide to Smartphone Storage Cleanup →

To request a hearing, a person must file within 60 days of receiving the reconsideration decision. The same 60-plus-10-day deadline rule applies. Once the request is filed, the wait time for a hearing can be substantial. In many parts of the country, people wait 6 to 18 months for a hearing date, depending on the ALJ's schedule and the volume of cases in the area. Some areas have shorter waits, while others may take longer.

During the hearing, the person has an opportunity to tell their story. They can explain how their condition affects their ability to work, describe medical treatment, and respond to questions from the judge. The person can bring medical records, work documents, letters from doctors, or statements from family members or employers. If the person has difficulty attending in person, they may request a hearing by phone or video conference.

Having a representative at the hearing is optional but often helpful. Social Security allows several types of representatives, including attorneys, non-attorney practitioners certified by Social Security, and in some cases, family members or friends. Representatives are familiar with the rules and evidence needed to win cases. Social Security records show that cases with representation have higher favorable decision rates compared to cases where the person appears alone, though representation is not necessary to win.

Preparing for a hearing is important. A person should gather all medical evidence, make a list of treatments and doctors, prepare a summary of how their condition limits work, and think about what they want to tell the judge. Many people benefit from meeting with their representative beforehand to discuss the case and practice what they will say.

After the hearing, the judge issues a written decision. This