Learn About Gift Card Resale Options

Understanding the Gift Card Resale Market

Gift cards have become one of the most popular gifts in the United States, with Americans spending over $160 billion on gift cards annually according to the National Retail Federation. However, not every gift card gets used. Research shows that approximately 20% of gift cards never get redeemed, and many recipients end up with cards they don't want or can't use. This situation has created a thriving secondary market where people can resell unwanted gift cards to other buyers.

Free Guide to Filing an LLC in Indiana →

The gift card resale market works as a marketplace where buyers and sellers connect to exchange gift cards. Sellers list cards they no longer want, and buyers purchase them, typically at a discount from the card's face value. The discount varies depending on the brand, current demand, and the card's condition. A gift card worth $100 to a popular retailer might sell for $85-$95, while cards to less popular stores might sell for $60-$80 of their face value.

Several factors drive this market. Some people receive duplicate gift cards, others get cards to stores they don't shop at, and some need cash more urgently than they need merchandise. On the buyer's side, people enjoy purchasing gift cards at reduced prices, which allows them to stretch their shopping budget further. This creates a win-win scenario where sellers convert unwanted cards into cash or store credit, and buyers get discounts on merchandise they actually want.

The resale market has grown significantly in recent years, with multiple platforms now facilitating these transactions. What was once limited to selling cards to friends or family now includes online marketplaces, specialized gift card resale websites, and even retail store buyback programs. Understanding how these different options work can help you make informed decisions about selling unwanted gift cards.

Practical Takeaway: Before selling a gift card, check its balance and expiration date. Some platforms won't accept expired cards, and knowing your card's exact value helps you price it competitively in the resale market.

Popular Gift Card Resale Websites and Platforms

Several dedicated platforms specialize in buying and selling gift cards. Raise.com, founded in 2012, operates as a peer-to-peer marketplace where individuals list gift cards for sale. The platform handles the transaction and charges both buyers and sellers a percentage fee. Sellers typically receive 85-95% of their asking price after fees. The website reports millions of gift cards sold through its platform, making it one of the largest resale marketplaces available.

Get Your Free Chocolate Sauce Recipe Guide →

Cardcash.com offers another option for selling gift cards. This platform both buys gift cards directly from users and operates a marketplace where people can sell to other users. When you sell directly to Cardcash, you typically receive 60-85% of the card's face value, depending on the brand and current demand. Their marketplace option allows you to list cards at higher prices, similar to Raise. Cardcash maintains an inventory of over one million cards from various retailers.

StockX, primarily known for buying and selling sneakers and collectibles, has expanded into the gift card market. The platform allows users to resell gift cards from major retailers. Their model emphasizes authentication and buyer protection, which can appeal to those concerned about fraud. However, their commission structure means sellers typically receive less than some other platforms.

Other platforms worth exploring include Gameflip, which specializes in gift cards and digital items; Decluttr, which buys gift cards among other items; and Facebook Marketplace, where individuals can sell directly to local buyers without intermediaries. Each platform has different fee structures, processing times, and card selection. Some platforms focus on specific retailers, while others accept a broader range of stores.

Traditional e-commerce platforms like eBay and Amazon also facilitate gift card sales, though these require more individual seller management and may have higher fees. Some sellers use multiple platforms to increase visibility and find the best price for their specific card.

Practical Takeaway: Before listing your card, research which platform your specific retailer's gift card sells for best. Popular retail chains typically sell faster and at higher percentages of face value than regional or specialty store cards.

Retail Store Buyback Programs

Many major retailers and restaurant chains operate their own gift card buyback programs, offering another direct resale option. Target, Walmart, Best Buy, and Starbucks are among the retailers that periodically buy gift cards from other brands. These programs vary in what they accept, how much they pay, and how quickly they process transactions.

Free Guide to Nail Fungus Treatment Options →

Best Buy's program, for example, allows customers to sell unwanted gift cards at their physical locations. You bring in the card, provide your identification, and receive payment either as store credit or a Best Buy gift card. The store typically offers 85-95% of the card's value, depending on the retailer and demand. The transaction happens immediately, making this option appealing if you want quick payment without waiting for online sales.

Walmart operates a similar in-store program where customers can exchange unwanted gift cards for Walmart gift cards or cash. Costco locations also have gift card exchanges, though their programs may be more limited. Some grocery chains like Kroger have tested buyback programs as well, though availability varies by location and changes periodically.

The advantage of retail buyback programs is the speed and security. You're selling directly to a major company, eliminating concerns about payment fraud or scams. The disadvantage is that you typically receive less money than you might get by selling to individual buyers on resale platforms. You also may be limited to specific brands the retailer partners with or currently accepts.

Restaurant chains including Starbucks, Chipotle, and Olive Garden sometimes participate in buyback programs through specialty platforms. These programs allow customers to sell unused restaurant gift cards for cash or store credit. The terms vary significantly, so checking directly with the restaurant or their website provides the most current information about their specific programs.

Practical Takeaway: Contact your local Best Buy, Walmart, or Costco to ask about their current gift card buyback programs. Policies change seasonally, so calling ahead ensures you have accurate information about current rates and accepted cards.

Understanding Fees, Rates, and Pricing

Gift card resale rates vary significantly based on multiple factors. The brand reputation of the retailer, seasonal demand, card balance amount, and how recently the card was purchased all influence its resale value. Popular retailers like Amazon, Target, and Whole Foods typically command higher resale prices—often 90-98% of face value—because demand for these cards remains consistently strong. Specialty or regional store cards may sell for only 50-70% of face value due to limited buyer interest.

Get Your Free Home Energy Savings Guide →

Fee structures differ across platforms. Peer-to-peer marketplaces like Raise charge sellers between 1-2% of the sale price, while also charging buyers a small percentage. When you sell a $100 Amazon gift card for $95 on Raise, you might receive $92-93 after their seller fee. Direct buyback programs operated by platforms like Cardcash typically take a larger cut, paying sellers 60-85% of face value upfront. Retail store buyback programs usually offer rates between 85-95% but provide immediate payment.

Pricing your card competitively matters when using marketplace platforms. If you list a gift card too high compared to other similar cards, it won't sell. Most successful sellers price their cards between 5-15% below face value on marketplace platforms, which still provides better value to buyers compared to paying full price while giving sellers cash they might not otherwise have. Checking comparable listings before setting your price increases the likelihood of your card selling quickly.

Card balance also affects resale value. A $10 gift card to a major retailer might sell at 95% of face value, but a $500 gift card to the same retailer might sell at 90% due to the larger buyer commitment. Some platforms also apply minimum balance requirements—they may only accept cards with balances above $5 or $10. Partial-balance cards (those with remaining balance after some use) sell at proportionally lower rates, since the buyer is essentially purchasing a partially used card.

Promotional factors influence pricing too. During major shopping seasons or when retailers run special promotions, gift cards to those stores sometimes command slightly higher resale prices. Conversely, if a retailer announces financial difficulties or store closures, their gift cards may suddenly decrease in value on the resale market.

Practical Takeaway: Calculate your net payment across different platforms before choosing where to sell. A