BJ's Wholesale Club operates two main credit card products: the BJ's Mastercard and the BJ's American Express card. These are distinct from a general membership at BJ's and represent a separate financial product managed through a banking partner. Understanding the structural differences between these cards helps you determine which aligns better with how you shop and spend.
Your Free Guide to Capital One Credit Card Options →
The BJ's Mastercard functions as a co-branded card issued by Comenity Capital Bank. This card works everywhere Mastercard is accepted, not just at BJ's locations. The BJ's American Express card, by contrast, is issued by American Express and operates within the American Express network. Both cards require you to have an active BJ's membership to open an account, though membership and the credit card are technically separate commitments. This means you're paying for membership whether or not you use the credit card.
Each card carries an annual fee. The BJ's Mastercard charges $55 per year, though BJ's occasionally runs promotions that waive the first-year fee for new cardholders. The BJ's American Express card has a $120 annual fee but offers additional perks that some members consider valuable enough to justify the higher cost. Neither card is a debit card—both are credit products that you need to pay back monthly.
The cards reward you through a cash back or rewards structure rather than points. With the Mastercard, you earn cash back on purchases made at BJ's and dining establishments. With American Express, the rewards structure focuses heavily on BJ's purchases but includes travel and other category bonuses. The redemption process differs between the two cards, which affects how quickly you can use your rewards.
Practical takeaway: Before considering either card, verify that you already have or want an active BJ's membership, since the card requires this as a prerequisite. Compare the annual fees against the cash back rates to see whether one card's rewards structure aligns with your spending patterns.
The rewards structure between BJ's two credit cards shows meaningful differences that compound over time. The BJ's Mastercard offers 1% cash back on most purchases outside of BJ's and participating restaurants, but escalates to higher rates on specific categories. At BJ's locations, the cash back rate is higher—currently 2% for most members, though this can increase to 3% during promotional periods or for certain membership tiers. At participating restaurants nationwide, you earn 2% cash back.
Get Your Free GameStop Credit Card Information Guide →
The BJ's American Express card structures rewards differently. You earn 5% cash back on purchases made at BJ's gas stations, 3% cash back on other BJ's purchases, and 1% on all other American Express transactions. The higher rates at the gas pump and on most BJ's shopping reflect the card issuer's bet that members will do substantial in-store spending. Gas purchases can represent a significant budget category for households, which is why this rate differential matters in real spending scenarios.
To understand which card produces better rewards for your situation, you need to map your actual spending. Consider a household that spends $8,000 annually at BJ's, $1,500 at restaurants, and $2,000 on gas at BJ's pumps. With the Mastercard (2% at BJ's, 2% at restaurants), you'd earn $160 at BJ's, $30 at restaurants, and $40 on gas purchases—totaling $230 in annual cash back. The American Express card (3% at BJ's, 5% on gas) would generate $240 at BJ's, $0 at restaurants, and $100 on gas—totaling $340 before considering the $120 annual fee. After the fee, you'd net $220—less than the Mastercard in this scenario.
However, if that same household spent $15,000 annually at BJ's and $3,000 on BJ's gas, the math shifts. The American Express would generate $450 at BJ's and $150 on gas, totaling $600 before the fee—netting $480. This demonstrates why knowing your spending habits matters more than comparing advertised rates alone.
Both cards offer occasional promotional categories or bonus periods. BJ's regularly announces these through email to cardholders and on the club's website. These promotions might offer 3% or 4% cash back during particular months, which can temporarily boost rewards during high-spending periods like back-to-school shopping or holiday seasons.
Practical takeaway: Pull your bank and credit card statements from the past year and categorize your spending at BJ's, restaurants, gas stations, and other locations. Calculate what each card would have earned you based on current rates. This actual data beats any general recommendation for determining which card genuinely serves your budget better.
The annual fee represents a real cost that you need to offset through rewards to see actual value from holding the card. The BJ's Mastercard's $55 annual fee means you need to earn at least that much in cash back annually for the card to break even. At BJ's 2% cash back rate, you'd need to spend $2,750 per year at the warehouse to offset the fee. For households that visit BJ's primarily for a monthly stock-up run rather than frequent trips, this threshold might be reachable. For others, particularly if you have less predictable shopping patterns, the fee could exceed your rewards.
Learn How USAA Auto Insurance Works →
The BJ's American Express card's $120 annual fee represents a higher hurdle. You need to generate $120 in cash back rewards to break even. Given that you earn 3% cash back on general BJ's purchases, you'd need approximately $4,000 in annual BJ's spending to offset this fee. If you frequently buy gas at BJ's at the 5% rate, the math improves—you'd only need $2,400 in combined gas and BJ's shopping to hit the break-even point. This card works better for members who visit BJ's regularly and buy higher quantities per trip.
BJ's occasionally waives the first-year annual fee for new cardholders as a promotional incentive. This gives you a year to evaluate whether the card's rewards actually exceed its annual cost without the fee barrier on year one. However, after that introductory period ends, you'll pay the full fee unless you cancel before the renewal date.
You can contact BJ's or the card issuer to request a fee waiver if you haven't received one automatically, though there's no guarantee they'll grant this request. Some cardholders have reported success asking about retention offers if they've maintained the card for several years. The timing of this conversation matters—making the request near your renewal date sometimes produces better results than asking early in your card year.
If you determine the card doesn't make financial sense for your spending, you can close the account. The annual fee is non-refundable once charged, but you won't be charged again the following year after cancellation. Closing a credit card does appear on your credit report, but it's a normal activity that doesn't severely damage credit scores compared to carrying high balances or missing payments.
Practical takeaway: Set a phone reminder for one month before your card's annual fee renewal date. At that time, review your actual cash back earnings from the past year. If rewards fell short of the annual fee, either request a fee waiver or plan to close the account before the renewal charges.
Redeeming rewards from a BJ's credit card isn't automatic—you need to understand the process for each card type, since they work differently. With the BJ's Mastercard, your cash back accumulates in an account tied to your card. You can redeem this cash back in several ways: as a statement credit applied to your bill, as a deposit to a bank account you've linked to the card, or in some cases, as cash back at the register when you make a purchase. The redemption process happens through the card issuer's online portal or mobile app, or by calling customer service.
Your Free Guide to AARP Travel Insurance Plans →
The BJ's American Express card handles redemptions through American Express's rewards platform. You can redeem your accumulated rewards as a statement credit, transfer to certain travel partners, or receive a check. American Express typically allows redemptions once your rewards balance reaches a certain threshold—often $25 or more. The redemption takes several business days to process, so it
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.