HP printers tell you when a cartridge is running low—sometimes in obvious ways, sometimes in ways that catch people off guard. The most common signal is a message on your printer's screen or on your computer saying the cartridge is low or empty. You might also notice your printed pages look faded or have streaky lines through them, especially if you're printing photos or documents with lots of color. Some HP printers will refuse to print at all once a cartridge is completely empty, as a built-in protection to keep you from damaging the printer.
Learn About Paying Your FGUA Bill Online →
What catches many people is that an HP printer might say a cartridge is "low" but still has several weeks of printing left in it. Other times, a cartridge that shows as low will work fine for months. This happens because HP's cartridge-level detection isn't always precise—it's based on an estimate, not an actual measurement of ink remaining. The printer counts how many pages you've printed since the cartridge was installed and makes a guess about how much ink is left. If you print documents with very little color, your cartridge might last longer than the estimate suggests.
You should consider replacing a cartridge when: the printer displays a "replace cartridge" message and printing quality noticeably declines, your prints look washed out or have missing colors, or you see warning lights on the printer itself. Some people also replace cartridges on a schedule—for instance, replacing them every six months if they print regularly—rather than waiting for the printer to complain. This approach can prevent the frustration of a cartridge dying mid-project.
Practical takeaway: Pay attention to both what your printer tells you and what your printed pages actually look like. A low-cartridge warning doesn't always mean you need to replace it today, but faded or streaky printing is a clear sign that replacement should happen soon.
Before you buy a replacement cartridge, you need to know exactly which model printer you own and which cartridges it uses. HP makes hundreds of printer models, and using the wrong cartridge can damage your printer or produce poor results. The good news is that finding this information takes just a few minutes.
Free Guide to Pay by Plate Illinois Billing →
Your printer model number is usually printed on a label on the back or bottom of the physical printer. Look for something like "HP LaserJet Pro M404n" or "HP OfficeJet 8015." If you can't find the physical label, you can locate it through your computer. On Windows, go to Settings > Devices > Printers & Scanners, find your printer name in the list, click it, and select "Printer Properties." On a Mac, go to System Preferences > Printers & Scanners, select your printer, and look for the model information. You can also check the original box your printer came in or look at your printer's manual if you still have it.
Once you have your model number, you need to know which cartridges it uses. HP cartridges come in different types: standard capacity cartridges are the most common and most affordable, while high-capacity (or XL) cartridges hold more ink and cost more per cartridge but may be cheaper per page if you print a lot. Some printers also use combination cartridges that contain both black and color ink in one unit. Visit HP's official website and enter your printer model in their cartridge finder tool. This will show you exactly which cartridge numbers work with your printer—for example, an HP 64 cartridge is different from an HP 65, even though they might fit in the same printer slot.
A common mistake is buying based on color alone. HP cartridges are usually labeled as black (single cartridges) or color (which may contain cyan, magenta, and yellow in one unit, or three separate cartridges). Check whether your printer needs one black cartridge and one color cartridge, or if it uses separate cartridges for each color. Your printer's manual or the HP website will show you the exact configuration for your model.
Practical takeaway: Write down your exact printer model number and take a photo of it before you shop. Cross-reference this with HP's cartridge finder to make absolutely certain you're buying the right cartridges—buying the wrong type wastes money and creates frustration.
When you're ready to buy a cartridge, you'll face a choice: original HP cartridges or compatible/third-party alternatives. This choice significantly affects your total spending, and the right answer depends on your situation and priorities.
Free Guide to Mold Removal Methods for Walls →
Original HP cartridges are manufactured by HP and come with a full warranty. They're the most expensive option—an HP 65 XL black cartridge typically costs $30 to $40, while an HP 65 XL color cartridge costs $35 to $45. However, original cartridges are engineered specifically for your printer, they're guaranteed to work, and they come with HP's customer support if something goes wrong. If you print important documents, photos, or anything you're submitting professionally, original cartridges reduce the risk of quality problems.
Compatible cartridges (also called third-party or remanufactured cartridges) are made by other companies but designed to work in HP printers. These typically cost $10 to $20 per cartridge. Remanufactured cartridges are empty original cartridges that have been refilled and tested. Compatible cartridges are brand new units made by third-party manufacturers. Both types work in many HP printers, but they don't all work equally well. Some deliver excellent results; others produce faded colors, streaky lines, or printing problems. The variability is the main drawback.
Here's the real math: if you print 20 pages per week, you might use one cartridge every four to five months. Over a year, you'd spend roughly $120 to $160 on original HP cartridges, or $40 to $80 on compatible alternatives. If the compatible cartridges work well for you, you save significant money. If they don't, you've wasted money on poor quality and spent time troubleshooting. Many people try one set of compatible cartridges first; if they're happy with the results, they keep buying that brand. If they're disappointed, they switch to original HP cartridges.
There's also a middle ground: HP's own cartridge recycling and refill programs. HP's Planet Partners program takes back empty cartridges (of any brand) for recycling, and some retailers offer cartridge refill services that cost less than buying new compatible cartridges. Check whether local printing shops or office supply stores near you offer in-store refilling—the cost is often $8 to $15 per cartridge.
Practical takeaway: Start by buying one set of compatible cartridges from a brand with good online reviews if you want to save money. If you're satisfied with the quality, stick with that brand. If not, switch to original HP cartridges—the investment in quality outweighs the savings from repeatedly buying poor-performing alternatives.
Replacing a cartridge is a straightforward physical task that takes five to ten minutes. The process varies slightly depending on your printer type, but the principles are the same for most HP models.
How to Delete Your Fitbit Account Guide →
Before you start: Turn off your printer and unplug it from the power outlet. This is important for your safety and to prevent the printer from trying to move mechanical parts while you're working inside it. Wait a minute or two for any moving parts to stop completely. Have your new cartridge ready and nearby, along with the empty cartridge you're removing. Keep the packaging from your new cartridge within reach—if the installation doesn't work, you may need to return the cartridge, and the original packaging helps with that.
Opening the printer: Most HP printers have a lid or cover that opens to reveal the cartridge slots. Lift this cover fully and hold it in place. Some models have a latch or button you need to press to open it. If your printer has a small door on the side or front rather than a top-opening lid, look for a small latch or release button and pull firmly. The compartment that holds the cartridges should be clearly visible inside—you'll see colored plastic slots or holders.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.