Instacart+ is Instacart's paid membership program that costs $9.99 per month or $99 per year. The membership promises free delivery on orders over $35 and reduced service fees on purchases. Before canceling, it helps to understand what you'll actually lose access to and whether those benefits align with your shopping habits.
Learn About Paying Your FGUA Bill Online →
The core question isn't whether cancellation is right for everyone—it's whether the membership pays for itself based on your actual usage patterns. If you place fewer than two orders per month, the math often doesn't work in your favor. Someone who shops once monthly might spend $120 annually on membership but only save $25 in fees and delivery charges. That's money flowing the wrong direction.
Conversely, if you're ordering groceries through Instacart three or four times weekly, Instacart+ becomes genuinely valuable. A household spending $50 per order would normally pay $5.99 delivery fees and percentage-based service fees totaling around $8 per order. Over a month, that's roughly $52 in fees on four orders. The membership pays for itself.
Here's what changes when you cancel: You'll still use Instacart, but standard delivery fees (currently $3.99 to $5.99 depending on order size and location) will apply. Service fees, which typically run 5-10% of your order total, return to normal. Instacart+ members also receive priority customer service, which downgraded accounts lose.
Practical takeaway: Before canceling, calculate your actual monthly spending with and without the membership. Track one full month of orders and fees, then decide whether the membership justified its cost based on your real behavior, not theoretical scenarios.
The most straightforward cancellation method happens directly in the Instacart mobile app, which works on both iPhone and Android devices. The process takes about two minutes and requires no phone calls or customer service interactions.
Free Guide to Pay by Plate Illinois Billing →
Start by opening the Instacart app and tapping the account icon in the bottom-right corner. This opens your profile menu. Look for "Instacart+" or "Membership" in this menu—the exact wording varies slightly between app versions and regions. Tap on that option to see your current membership details, including your renewal date and payment method.
Once you're viewing your membership information, you'll see a button or link labeled "Manage Membership" or "Change Membership." Tap this. The app will show you options to modify your membership status. Look specifically for text saying "Cancel Membership" or "Turn Off Auto-Renewal." This is the critical button—don't confuse it with pausing your membership, which temporarily suspends benefits but keeps billing active.
When you tap the cancellation option, Instacart typically displays a confirmation screen asking you to verify the action. This screen might include a brief survey asking why you're canceling. You can skip this survey or answer it—both lead to the same outcome. Confirm the cancellation when prompted. Once completed, you'll see a confirmation message stating your membership has been canceled.
Important timing note: If you cancel mid-cycle (say, on the 15th of a month when your renewal date is the 30th), you keep your membership benefits through the original renewal date. You won't be charged again after that date. Instacart doesn't prorate refunds for mid-cycle cancellations, so there's no money returned for unused portions of your membership period.
Practical takeaway: Cancellation through the app is reliable and leaves a digital record you can reference. Take a screenshot of the confirmation message for your records—this protects you if billing issues occur later.
If you prefer managing your account on a computer, Instacart's website offers the same cancellation functionality as the mobile app. The process is nearly identical but uses a slightly different menu structure adapted for desktop browsing.
Free Guide to Mold Removal Methods for Walls →
Navigate to instacart.com and log into your account using your email and password. Once logged in, look for your account profile—typically found by clicking your name or profile icon in the top-right corner of the page. This opens a dropdown menu with various account options. Select "Account Settings" or "Account" from this menu.
Within Account Settings, you'll find a section dedicated to subscription or membership information. This section displays your current Instacart+ status, billing date, and associated payment method. Click on "Membership" or "Manage Subscription" to access detailed options.
The membership management page shows your renewal schedule and provides buttons or links for modifying your subscription. Look for "Cancel Membership" or similar language. Click this option. Like the app version, the website will ask you to confirm the cancellation. Some regions may display a brief survey about your cancellation reason before finalizing the process.
One advantage of the web version: you can clearly see your billing history and renewal date before canceling. This helps you understand exactly when charges will stop. If you're canceling on the 20th of the month but your renewal date is the 10th of next month, you still have paid benefits for the next 20 days. This information displays more clearly on the website than in most app versions.
Practical takeaway: The web browser approach works especially well if you're reviewing your account history or payment methods alongside cancellation. You can access all your membership details on one screen without navigating between menu layers.
Canceling Instacart+ doesn't delete your account or shopping history. You retain your full Instacart user profile, order history, saved shopping lists, and payment methods on file. You simply revert to using Instacart as a non-paying customer with standard fees applied.
How to Delete Your Fitbit Account Guide →
Your saved items and shopping lists remain accessible. If you had a recurring order set up for weekly milk and eggs, that order continues to work—you'll just pay standard delivery and service fees instead of enjoying Instacart+ benefits. Your delivery address stays saved, your payment methods remain stored, and your order history remains viewable. Nothing gets deleted or lost.
The financial difference becomes immediately apparent with your next order. Where an Instacart+ member might see a $3 delivery fee and $6 in service fees on a $50 order, a non-member at the same supermarket sees $5.99 delivery and around $7.50 in service fees. Over the course of months, these per-order differences accumulate. On twenty orders annually, that's roughly $50-70 in additional fees compared to membership holders.
Instacart may occasionally send you promotional offers about reactivating membership. You might receive emails saying "Come back to Instacart+ for $4.99 per month" or similar limited-time pricing. These promotions are common and appear somewhat regularly to canceled members. Opening such emails and considering re-enrollment is entirely optional—there's no penalty for staying canceled or reactivating later.
One unexpected benefit of cancellation: you now see Instacart's actual fees more clearly. Some people find that confronting the true cost of grocery delivery changes their behavior—they might consolidate orders into larger, less frequent purchases or occasionally choose in-person shopping for smaller items. This shift sometimes leads to overall spending reduction despite higher per-order fees.
Practical takeaway: Keep your password and account login information stored safely. You might want to re-join Instacart+ in the future, and reactivating an existing account is faster than creating a new one from scratch.
Most cancellations process smoothly, but occasionally billing problems occur. Perhaps you canceled but received an unexpected charge, or the app confirmation screen glitched and you're unsure if cancellation actually went through. Here's how to verify and address these situations.
Learn How to Grow Sweet Corn at Home →
First, check your payment method records directly. Log into your credit card or bank account and search for Instacart charges. Look at the transaction dates and amounts. If you canceled on March 15th and your next Instacart charge appears on April 15th, something went wrong. If your last charge was March 10th and nothing appears scheduled for April, cancellation likely succeeded.
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.