When you move into a new home or apartment, you often don't know who has copies of the keys. Previous owners, real estate agents, contractors, and maintenance workers may all have had access to your locks at some point. This is one of the most overlooked security gaps in residential properties. Rekeying changes the internal pin configuration of your lock so that old keys no longer work—only your new key will open the door. It's different from replacing the entire lock, which is more expensive and time-consuming.
Learn About Paying Your FGUA Bill Online →
Schlage locks are among the most common residential locks in North America, found in millions of homes, apartments, and rental properties. They're popular because they're durable, relatively affordable, and compatible with many different door types and configurations. If your property has Schlage locks, understanding how to rekey them (or what goes into the process) gives you real control over your home's security from day one.
Rekeying becomes necessary in several real situations. You've moved into a previously occupied home. You've lost a key and aren't sure who might have found it. You've had a roommate, tenant, or household member move out. You've hired contractors who needed temporary access. In rental properties, landlords typically rekey between tenants as a standard practice—though this cost is usually borne by the property owner, not the tenant.
The cost difference matters: a full lock replacement can run $150–$300 per door, while rekeying typically costs $15–$40 per lock when done by a professional locksmith. If you have multiple Schlage locks throughout your property, the savings add up quickly. Understanding what rekeying involves helps you make informed decisions about which locks need attention and how to budget for this maintenance.
Practical takeaway: Before deciding whether to rekey your Schlage locks, inventory how many you have and which ones control access to your most sensitive areas—exterior doors, garage entries, and side doors are the priority targets for rekeying after a move or security concern.
A pin tumbler lock, which is what most Schlage residential locks use, contains a series of small pins stacked inside a cylinder. When you insert the correct key, the cuts on that key align these pins at precisely the right heights. This allows the cylinder to turn, retracting the bolt and unlocking the door. When you insert an incorrect key (or no key at all), the pins don't align properly, and the cylinder won't turn.
Free Guide to Pay by Plate Illinois Billing →
Rekeying means removing the cylinder from the lock body, taking out the current pins, and installing a new set of pins cut to match a different key. The lock housing itself stays in place—you're not disturbing the bolt mechanism, the strike plate, or the door installation. This is why it's so much faster and cheaper than removing and replacing an entire lock unit.
Here's what happens during a professional rekey: The locksmith removes the lock cylinder from the door (usually by opening the interior side of the lock). They then extract the old pin stack using a special tool. The new pins—cut to your new key's specifications—are inserted into the cylinder in the correct order. The cylinder is reassembled and reinstalled in the lock housing. The whole process typically takes 5–15 minutes per lock once the locksmith arrives.
One important detail: You can't mix and match randomly. A Schlage lock can be rekeyed to work with your existing key (if you already have a Schlage key you want to use for all your locks) or to a completely new key. Many property owners choose to rekey all their exterior locks to use the same key for convenience. This is called "keying alike" and costs the same as individual rekeying.
Some Schlage locks, particularly high-security or commercial models, have additional security features that complicate rekeying or may require specialized tools. Residential Schlage models, however, are straightforward to rekey. The lock design has remained relatively consistent for decades, so information about one generation applies broadly to most Schlage residential products.
Practical takeaway: When calling a locksmith for a quote, ask whether they can key all your locks alike (so one key works everywhere) or whether you need separate keys for different areas—this choice affects your quote and your daily convenience.
Moving into a new or different home is the single most common trigger for rekeying. You have no history with the locks and no way to verify who has copies of the existing keys. Real estate transactions involve many people handling keys: the previous owners, their family members, the real estate agents showing the property, home inspectors, appraisers, and contractors who may have visited for repairs or inspections. Even if the previous owner was trustworthy, you can't control what those other people did with key copies. Rekeying on move-in day eliminates this uncertainty.
Free Guide to Mold Removal Methods for Walls →
Rental situations add another layer. If you're renting and concerned about privacy or security, you may want to request that your landlord rekey the locks when you move in. Many landlords do this automatically, but some don't—it's worth asking. If you're a landlord, rekeying between every tenant is standard property maintenance and protects both the security of your property and the privacy of incoming residents.
Lost or stolen keys create a real security gap. If you've lost a key and it's been missing for weeks or months, you don't know where it is or who might find it. You have three options: rekey the lock, replace the lock, or do nothing and accept the risk. Most security-conscious homeowners rekey in this situation, since it's the lowest-cost option that definitively solves the problem.
Life changes also warrant rekeying. A household member who had access (a roommate, adult child, ex-partner) no longer lives with you. A contractor, nanny, house cleaner, or other service provider who had a key no longer works for you. You're ending a house-sitting arrangement. In all these cases, the person may still have their copy of the key—rekeying is the only way to ensure they can't reenter without permission.
Security concerns after a break-in or attempted break-in make rekeying a logical step. If someone has tampered with your locks or you suspect lock picking, rekeying combined with an inspection of lock damage helps you move forward with confidence. Similarly, if you've discovered that a lock was defective or worn out, rekeying gives you a chance to assess and replace damaged hardware at the same time.
Practical takeaway: Create a timeline for rekeying: when you move in (urgent), when household members leave (medium priority), and after any security incident (immediate). This helps you plan costs and prioritize which locks to address first.
Rekeying a Schlage lock is technically possible for a homeowner to do themselves, but it requires specific tools and knowledge. The main tool you need is a plug follower—a specialized device that prevents the spring-loaded pins from falling out when you remove the cylinder. You also need a key decoder (to determine which pins you need), replacement pin kits, and sometimes a pick tool to manipulate the lock cylinder. A basic rekeying kit for Schlage locks costs $20–$60 online.
How to Delete Your Fitbit Account Guide →
The learning curve is real. Your first rekey will likely take 30–45 minutes even if everything goes smoothly. You need to understand pin heights (they're numbered 0–9), match them to your key's cuts, insert them in the correct order, and reassemble the lock without losing small metal pieces. One mistake—inserting a pin backwards or at the wrong height—and your new key won't work. Some people successfully DIY their first rekey; others spend an hour frustrated before calling a locksmith.
The financial comparison is straightforward. A professional locksmith charges $15–$40 per lock, plus a service call fee that ranges from $50–$100 depending on your location. If you have one lock, professional service costs $65–$140. If you DIY, you spend $20–$60 on tools and supplies. If you have three locks, professional service costs $95–$220 (depending on whether the locksmith can do multiple locks during one visit), and DIY still costs only $20–$60 for the supplies
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.