When you're ready to upgrade your phone, trading in your old device is one of the most practical ways to offset the cost of a new one. But understanding how trade-ins actually work—and what affects their value—can save you hundreds of dollars over time. This guide walks through the real mechanics of phone trade-ins, from carrier programs to retail options, so you can make informed decisions about your device.
Learn About Paying Your FGUA Bill Online →
Phone trade-in programs exist because carriers and retailers have discovered a profitable cycle: they take your old phone, refurbish it, and resell it in secondary markets or use it for parts. This means they're willing to offer you money or credit toward a new purchase. The amount varies dramatically depending on the device's condition, age, model, and market demand. A three-year-old flagship phone in excellent condition might fetch $300 in trade-in credit, while the same phone with screen damage might be worth $75.
Several major carriers run their own trade-in programs. Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile, and US Cellular all offer trade-in values that can be applied toward monthly bill credits or the purchase price of a new phone. Retail stores like Best Buy, Target, and Walmart also run trade-in programs. Even Apple, Samsung, and Google operate their own trade-in initiatives through their websites. Each program has different requirements, different payment structures, and different phones they prioritize.
The critical insight: not all trade-in programs value the same phone equally. A device worth $250 at one carrier might be worth $200 at another. This is why preparation and comparison matter before you hand over your device.
Practical takeaway: Before trading in, research at least three different programs (your current carrier, a major retailer, and the manufacturer) to compare offers for your specific model and condition.
Trade-in programs typically use a standardized condition rating system, but what counts as "good," "fair," or "poor" varies by program. Understanding these categories in detail helps you anticipate what your phone will actually receive as a valuation. Most programs use four to five tiers: like new or mint, excellent or good, fair, and poor or parts-only.
Free Guide to Pay by Plate Illinois Billing →
A phone rated "like new" has no visible damage, functions perfectly, includes the original box and accessories, and has minimal battery degradation. These phones command the highest trade-in values, sometimes 60–70% of the original retail price for recent models. A phone rated "excellent" or "good" has light cosmetic wear—maybe a small scratch on the body or minor wear on the edges—but no cracks, the screen works perfectly, and battery health is above 80%. These typically receive 40–60% of the original retail price.
The "fair" category is where condition becomes murky. This usually includes phones with visible scratches or scuffs on the body, minor screen imperfections that don't affect functionality, or battery health between 60–79%. Trade-in value drops to 20–40% of the original retail price. A phone rated "poor" has significant damage: visible cracks, dead pixels, severely degraded battery, water damage, or operational issues. These may only receive 5–15% of the original price or might be offered parts-only value with no cash credit.
Before submitting your phone for trade-in, do a detailed inspection. Power on the device and check that the screen displays correctly across all colors. Test speakers, microphones, buttons, and sensors. Look at the phone under bright light for hairline cracks or water damage indicators (small colored dots inside ports). Check battery health using your phone's built-in tools: on iPhones, go to Settings > Battery Health & Charging; on Android, the process varies by manufacturer.
Clean your phone thoroughly before the trade-in process. Wipe down the screen and body with a microfiber cloth. Remove any protective cases or screen protectors—some programs want to see the device as-is, and removing protection can reveal unexpected damage. Back up all data and perform a factory reset so the device is wiped completely.
Practical takeaway: Document your phone's condition with photos before trading it in. If a program's valuation differs significantly from what you expected based on condition, you have visual evidence to reference in your dispute.
Each trade-in program has its own operational structure, and knowing these differences helps you choose the best fit for your situation. Carrier-based programs (Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile, US Cellular) typically require you to be an active customer, though some allow trade-ins even if you're not currently with them. Values are applied as bill credits or account credits, which means you don't receive cash—you receive service credit or a discount on your next device purchase.
Free Guide to Mold Removal Methods for Walls →
Verizon's program, for example, allows trade-ins whether you're a current customer or not. You can start the trade-in process online by entering your device model and condition. Verizon generates an estimate, which is not binding but gives you a ballpark. You then mail in your phone using a prepaid label. Once Verizon receives and inspects the device, it either confirms the estimated value or adjusts it based on actual condition. Credit is applied to your account, typically within 2–3 billing cycles. The trade-in value counts as account credit you can use toward a new device, plan, or accessories.
AT&T's program works similarly but includes an in-store option: you can trade in your phone at an AT&T store and receive credit on the spot for some devices. T-Mobile offers both mail-in and in-store options, with in-store inspections sometimes completing within minutes. US Cellular's program is smaller but operates on similar principles.
Best Buy's program accepts phones from any carrier and brand. You can check values online or in-store using an interactive tool. Best Buy offers several redemption options: Best Buy store credit (which is their highest payout), which you can use on any merchandise including phones, accessories, or services. This is different from carrier programs because you get retail credit, not service credit. Trade-ins can happen in-store on the spot or via mail.
Manufacturer programs (Apple, Samsung, Google) work through their own retail channels. Apple's trade-in program provides credit toward Apple Store purchases—devices, services, or accessories. Samsung offers credit toward Samsung devices or services. Google's Pixel trade-in program provides credit toward Pixel phones or Google Store purchases. These programs typically offer competitive values because they're integrated with their own device sales.
Third-party trade-in companies like Gazelle, Decluttr, and BuyBackWorld operate independently. These services mail you a prepaid shipping label, you send in your phone, and they send you a check or PayPal payment. The advantage: you receive actual cash, not store credit. The disadvantage: some offer lower values than carrier or manufacturer programs because they operate on tighter margins.
Practical takeaway: List your phone model and condition on three different platforms (one carrier, one retailer, one manufacturer) and note the values offered. Compare not just the dollar amount but also what the credit can be used for, since store credit may have limited usefulness to you.
One of the most overlooked steps in phone trade-in preparation is properly handling your personal data. Simply deleting visible files is not sufficient. Your phone stores data in multiple locations: the primary storage, backup caches, temporary files, and application data. Many of these are not deleted when you clear your Photos app or Messages.
How to Delete Your Fitbit Account Guide →
Start by backing up everything you want to keep. For iPhones, use iCloud or a Mac computer. Go to Settings > [Your Name] > iCloud, then toggle on the data types you want backed up: Photos, Mail, Contacts, Calendars, Notes, and others. For Android devices, use Google's built-in backup through Settings > System > Backup & Reset, or use Samsung Cloud if you own a Samsung phone. Give the backup process 30–60 minutes to complete, especially if you have a large photo library.
Next, sign out of all accounts before performing a factory reset. On iPhone, go to Settings > [Your Name] and tap "Sign Out." This removes your iCloud account from the device and prevents activation lock issues that could complicate the trade-in process
This guide is for general information only and is not medical, financial, legal, or other professional advice. For decisions specific to your situation, consult a qualified professional. See our Editorial Policy.