Get Your Free Gift Card Selling Information Guide

Understanding Gift Card Selling Markets and What Information You'll Need

Gift cards represent a significant financial market in the United States. According to the National Retail Federation, consumers purchased approximately 8.2 billion dollars worth of gift cards in 2023, with an estimated 2-3 billion dollars remaining unspent or underutilized each year. This creates a marketplace where people sell unused or partially used gift cards to recover cash or exchange them for cards they'll actually use.

Get Your Free Gopher Control Information Guide →

A free informational guide about gift card selling helps you understand the basic structure of this market. The guide explains how secondary gift card markets operate, including the different types of platforms available—from specialized gift card resale websites to general marketplace applications. You'll learn about the distinction between retail gift cards (such as those for restaurants, clothing stores, or entertainment venues) and restaurant-specific cards, as well as how these different card types may have different resale values.

The guide covers what information you'll typically need when you decide to sell a gift card. This includes:

• The original retailer name and logo information
• The remaining balance on the card (which you can usually check on the retailer's website)
• The condition of the physical card, if applicable
• The card number and PIN, which vary by platform in how they're handled
• Purchase date or other relevant card history

Understanding these baseline requirements helps you gather necessary information before approaching a resale platform. Most guides explain that different platforms have different standards for what they accept. Some platforms focus on popular national retailers while others may accept regional or specialized cards. Practical takeaway: Before attempting to sell a gift card, check your card's balance through the issuing retailer's website or by calling their customer service number. This single step prevents wasted effort on cards with minimal remaining value.

How Gift Card Resale Platforms Work and Their Different Operating Models

The gift card resale industry has developed several distinct business models, and an informational guide helps you understand how each operates. The three primary models include direct resale platforms, auction-style marketplaces, and trade-based systems.

Free Guide to Changing iPhone App Icons →

Direct resale platforms operate as intermediaries between buyers and sellers. Companies like Raise, Cardcash, and StockX Gift Cards purchase gift cards from sellers at a percentage of their face value—typically ranging from 60 to 90 percent depending on the card type and current demand. The platform then lists these cards for sale to buyers. The seller receives payment, but not the full card value, because the platform takes a commission and assumes the risk of selling the card. These platforms typically process transactions within 2-7 business days once a card sells.

Auction-style marketplaces function differently. Websites like eBay allow individuals to list gift cards and set either a fixed price or auction format where buyers bid. The seller sets the initial terms, and the marketplace takes a transaction fee (typically 2-3 percent for eBay). These platforms offer potentially higher returns if demand is strong, but involve more uncertainty since sales aren't guaranteed.

Trade-based systems represent a third model. Some platforms focus on card-to-card exchanges rather than cash transactions. For example, you might trade a $100 Starbucks card for a $95 Amazon card if that matches the platform's current exchange rates. These systems appeal to people who want different cards rather than cash, though they don't solve the problem of unused gift cards entirely.

Different platforms also handle sensitive information differently. Some require you to enter the complete card number and PIN into their system for verification. Others use different security protocols. A guide explains these variations so you understand what to expect. Practical takeaway: Research 2-3 platforms before selling your first gift card. Compare their payout percentages for the specific retailer you're selling, read their user reviews, and note their payment timelines. What offers the highest percentage may not offer the fastest payment.

Determining Fair Value and Understanding Price Fluctuations

Gift card resale prices fluctuate based on several market factors. A comprehensive informational resource explains these dynamics without guaranteeing any specific outcomes.

Free Guide to Schizophrenia Clinical Trial Opportunities →

Retailer popularity and seasonality significantly impact resale value. Popular retailers like Amazon, Target, Walmart, and Visa/Mastercard gift cards maintain relatively stable resale values—often 85-95 percent of face value. Specialty retailers experience more dramatic fluctuations. For instance, a gift card to a restaurant that recently received negative press might decrease in value to 50-70 percent of face value. Conversely, a card to a newly popular or trendy retailer might command 95+ percent of face value.

Seasonal factors matter considerably. Right after the winter holiday season (January-February), the supply of unused gift cards increases dramatically, which typically depresses prices. Summer months and fall leading into the holiday season see stronger demand as people seek cards to give as gifts. A guide explains these patterns so you understand why the same card might sell for different percentages at different times of year.

Platform competition also affects pricing. When multiple platforms offer to buy the same card, they compete for inventory, which can drive up the percentage they'll pay. Checking current offers across 2-3 platforms before selling shows you the range of available prices.

Card type and restrictions influence value. Cards with usage restrictions (such as cards that only work online or only in-store) typically sell for lower percentages than unrestricted cards. Digital-only cards often command higher prices because they're easier for platforms to process. Physical gift cards that require shipping may sell for slightly less due to handling costs.

The original purchase price and current availability of the retailer matters too. A card from a store that's closing or significantly reducing locations may be worth less. A card from an expanding retailer might be worth more. Practical takeaway: Before selling multiple gift cards from the same retailer, sell one at market rates to understand current pricing. Then decide whether to sell others immediately or wait for seasonal price movements that might benefit specific card types.

What to Know About Security, Fraud Prevention, and Protecting Your Information

Selling gift cards online involves sharing sensitive financial information, and a proper guide covers the security considerations you should understand. This isn't about paranoia—it's about informed decision-making.

Learn About Starting Your Own Bank →

When you list a gift card for sale on any platform, you're sharing the card number and often the PIN or security code. Once this information is in another person's possession, you lose control of the funds. Reputable platforms mitigate this risk through verification procedures. They confirm that the card balance matches what the seller claims, and they hold payment to the seller until the buyer receives and confirms the card works. This protects both parties.

However, scams do occur. Common schemes include sellers listing cards they don't own or cards with insufficient balance. Some sellers list cards that have already been spent. Platforms combat these issues through verification, but understanding the risk helps you make informed platform choices. Review platforms that publish their fraud statistics and dispute resolution processes.

When evaluating a platform's security measures, a guide helps you understand what to look for:

• Encrypted website connections (look for "https://" in the URL)
• Two-factor authentication options for your account
• Clear dispute resolution policies if transactions go wrong
• Information about how the platform verifies cards before paying sellers
• Whether the platform holds your payment in escrow until the buyer confirms receipt
• Privacy policies that explain how your information is stored and protected

Different platforms have different security standards. Some require photo verification of cards. Others require you to test the card balance before listing. Understanding these procedures helps you choose platforms that align with your comfort level.

One aspect often overlooked: the tax implications of selling gift cards. In most cases, selling a gift card for cash isn't a taxable event if you're selling it for less than the face value (you're not making a profit). However, if you're regularly selling large quantities of gift cards and making profit, this may constitute business income. A guide explains this distinction without providing tax advice, which you should seek from a qualified tax professional if you're selling substantial quantities.

Practical takeaway: Before sharing any card information online, verify that the platform uses encryption (check for the padlock icon in your browser) and review its specific policies about payment protection and fraud claims. Never sell a gift card on a platform that asks you to wire money to them or pay