Get Your Free Credit Card Dispute Resolution Guide

Understanding Credit Card Disputes: What You Need to Know

A credit card dispute occurs when you challenge a transaction on your card statement because you believe it's incorrect or unauthorized. This is a formal process governed by federal law, primarily through the Fair Credit Billing Act (FCBA). When you dispute a charge, your credit card issuer is required to investigate the transaction within specific timeframes.

Get Your Free Guide to State Property Tax Rates →

There are several common reasons people file disputes. Unauthorized transactions happen when someone uses your card without permission. Billing errors include being charged twice for the same purchase, being charged an amount different from what you agreed to, or having a transaction appear on your statement that you never authorized. Quality issues arise when you receive damaged or defective merchandise, or when a merchant fails to provide services you paid for. Processing errors occur when a merchant submits your transaction information incorrectly to the payment system.

According to the Federal Reserve, consumers file millions of credit card disputes annually. In 2022, the Federal Trade Commission received over 2.1 million fraud reports from consumers, with credit card fraud representing a significant portion. Understanding the dispute process helps you protect yourself and know your rights under federal consumer protection laws.

The distinction between a dispute and a chargeback is important. A dispute is your initial complaint to your credit card company. If the issuer's investigation doesn't resolve the matter in your favor, they may initiate a chargeback, which involves reversing the transaction and recovering funds from the merchant's bank. This escalation process protects consumers but also carries serious consequences for merchants.

Practical Takeaway: Keep detailed records of all your transactions and review your statements monthly. The sooner you notice and report a problematic charge, the better your position in a dispute. Most card issuers provide 60 days from when you receive your statement to file a dispute, but reporting quickly strengthens your case.

The Step-by-Step Dispute Process Your Card Issuer Must Follow

When you contact your credit card company about a disputed transaction, a specific legal process begins. Your issuer must acknowledge receipt of your dispute within 30 days. During this period, they should investigate the claim by reviewing the transaction details, contacting the merchant if necessary, and examining any evidence you provide.

Get Your Free Guide to Boscov's Credit Card Options →

The investigation phase typically lasts 30 to 90 days, depending on the dispute type. Your card issuer will examine documentation like order confirmations, shipping records, delivery proof, and communication with the merchant. If you're disputing an unauthorized transaction, they'll review whether the charge matches your typical spending patterns and whether you reported it promptly. For quality disputes, they may request photos of damaged merchandise or documentation of service failures.

During the investigation, your card issuer should credit your account temporarily for the disputed amount if the error appears valid. This provisional credit usually arrives within 10 business days. However, the temporary credit doesn't mean you've won the dispute—the issuer can still reverse it if their investigation determines the merchant's charge was legitimate. You're responsible for the amount if the dispute is decided against you, unless you have additional evidence to present.

Once the investigation concludes, your issuer must notify you of the outcome. If they rule in your favor, the temporary credit becomes permanent and the transaction is removed from your statement. If they rule against you, they'll explain their decision and restore the charge to your account. You have the right to request documentation of their investigation findings.

Throughout this process, federal law prohibits your issuer from reporting the disputed amount to credit bureaus as delinquent. Your credit score should not be negatively affected while a legitimate dispute is pending.

Practical Takeaway: Document every communication with your card issuer regarding your dispute. Keep records of phone calls (get names and confirmation numbers), emails, letters, and the dates you made contact. This paper trail proves you took action within the required timeframes and helps if you need to escalate the dispute.

Gathering and Presenting Evidence for Your Dispute

Strong evidence dramatically increases your chances of winning a credit card dispute. The type of evidence you need depends on your dispute category. For unauthorized transactions, document when you discovered the fraudulent charge, what you were doing on that date, your typical spending patterns, and whether anyone had access to your card information. If your card was physically stolen, the police report number strengthens your case.

Tractor Supply Credit Card Account Access Guide →

For transactions with unauthorized merchants—where someone charged your card without your permission—gather any communication showing you never approved the transaction. This includes emails declining a service, messages requesting cancellation, or documentation that you cancelled a subscription before being charged. If the merchant promised not to charge you and then did, save those communications.

Quality and service disputes require different evidence. Photographs of damaged merchandise taken on the day you received it, showing the condition and the shipping box for context, help establish the item arrived defective. For services, document what you paid for versus what you received. If you hired someone to perform work and they didn't complete it, retain photos showing the incomplete work, along with text messages or emails where they acknowledged the situation.

Shipping and delivery disputes need proof of what happened to your purchase. Screenshots of tracking information showing "delivery confirmed" when you never received the item strengthen your case. If the merchant claimed you signed for delivery and you didn't, request the actual signature from them—many can't produce legitimate signatures, which supports your dispute.

Organization matters when presenting evidence. Create a simple document that lists the transaction date, merchant name, amount, and the reason for your dispute. Then attach evidence in chronological order. If you're submitting materials by mail, include a cover letter explaining the dispute briefly and referencing the attached evidence by type and date.

Practical Takeaway: Start gathering evidence immediately when you identify a problematic charge. Take screenshots of your online accounts, forward relevant emails to yourself, and photograph any physical items involved. Memories fade and digital records disappear, so capture everything while details are fresh.

What Happens When the Merchant Fights Back

When you file a dispute, the credit card company notifies the merchant's bank, which gives the merchant an opportunity to respond. Many merchants have processes in place to defend legitimate charges. They might provide proof of delivery, your signed receipt, or communication showing you authorized the transaction. Understanding this counterargument process helps you prepare stronger evidence.

Free Guide to Firestone Credit Card Online Account Management →

Merchants often use delivery confirmation as their primary defense in non-receipt disputes. If you claim you never received a package, the merchant will submit tracking information showing delivery. This is why your response matters—you need evidence that contradicts theirs. A signed delivery confirmation they claim you signed means you need to file a police report for mail theft or obtain a statement from whoever lives at your address denying they signed.

For quality disputes, merchants frequently argue that you simply changed your mind or misunderstood the product. They might provide their product description and argue it matches what they shipped. Photos of the actual item in poor condition defeat this argument. Videos unboxing the item can show both the damaged merchandise and the condition of packaging, proving the damage occurred during shipping, not through misuse.

Subscription or recurring charge disputes can be particularly contested. Merchants often produce their terms of service showing that charges continue until cancelled and argue you never submitted a cancellation request. This is why written cancellation requests—through email or documented customer service chats—are crucial. The merchant must acknowledge receipt, and your issuer can see whether they comply with cancellation requests promptly.

If the merchant successfully proves the charge was legitimate, your card issuer will rule against you and restore the charge. This doesn't mean the dispute process failed—it means the merchant had stronger evidence. You retain the option to pursue the matter through small claims court, file a complaint with your state attorney general, or work with the Better Business Bureau if the merchant engaged in deceptive practices.

Practical Takeaway: Don't assume a merchant won't respond to your dispute. Prepare your evidence as if you're arguing in front of a judge—clear, chronological, and focused on the facts. Anticipate what the merchant might say and provide evidence that directly contradicts their likely defense.

Your Rights and Protections Under Federal Law

The Fair Credit Billing Act, enacted in 1974 and amended multiple times, provides substantial protections for credit card users. Under this law, you cannot be held responsible for more than $50 in fraudulent charges on your credit card. If someone steals your card and makes unauthorized purchases, your maximum liability is typically nothing, provided you report the theft promptly. Most major card issuers don't charge cardholders anything

Free Guide to Understanding Credit Card Chip Technology →