Free Guide to Pokémon Card Grading Steps

Understanding Pokémon Card Grading Basics

Pokémon card grading is a process where third-party companies evaluate the condition of trading cards and assign them numerical grades. These grades range from 1 to 10, with 10 being a perfect card in mint condition. The grading system helps buyers and sellers understand exactly what they're purchasing or selling without having to see the card in person. When you submit a card for grading, professional evaluators examine every aspect of the card under controlled lighting and magnification.

Get Your Free Guide to Starlink Internet Options →

The grading scale works as follows: cards rated 1-2 are in poor condition with significant damage, cards rated 3-4 show heavy wear, cards rated 5-6 are in good or very good condition with noticeable use, cards rated 7-8 are in near mint to mint condition with minimal flaws, and cards rated 9-10 are gem mint to perfect condition. Most collectors aim for cards graded 7 or higher, though the specific grade needed depends on your goals and budget. Understanding this scale matters because a small difference in grade—say, a 7 versus an 8—can mean a significant difference in a card's market value.

Major grading companies that evaluate Pokémon cards include PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator), Beckett Grading Services (BGS/Subgrades), and CGC Cards. Each company has slightly different grading standards and holder designs, though the numerical grades are comparable across services. PSA is historically the most popular choice for Pokémon cards, but all three companies offer legitimate grading services. The graded card comes back in a sealed plastic holder with the grade displayed on a label, protecting the card from further damage while allowing it to be viewed.

Practical takeaway: Learn what the 1-10 grading scale means before you submit cards. Research which grading companies operate in your region and understand their different approaches, so you can decide which service matches your needs.

Evaluating Your Cards Before Submission

Before you spend money sending cards to a professional grader, you should examine your collection to determine which cards are worth grading. Not every Pokémon card benefits from professional grading—the cost of grading (typically $10 to $50+ per card depending on the service and turnaround time) means you should focus on cards that have real value. Cards from early sets like Base Set, Jungle, and Fossil released in 1999-2000 tend to hold higher values. Holographic or "holo" cards are generally worth more than non-holographic versions of the same card. First edition cards, identifiable by "1st Edition" printed on the left side of the card, typically command premium prices.

Get Your Free Guide to Movie Ticket Discounts for Seniors →

When you examine your own cards, look for visible damage that would affect their grade. Check the corners and edges for wear, whitening, or bending—these are extremely common issues that lower grades significantly. Examine the surface for scratches, creases, or print lines. Look at the centering, which means whether the image is properly centered within the card borders. Off-center cards are graded lower because the borders appear uneven. Check the back of the card as thoroughly as the front; graders evaluate both sides.

You can compare your cards to grading guides available on company websites and YouTube videos that show examples of different grades. These visual references help you understand what a Grade 7 versus a Grade 8 actually looks like in person. Many collectors use magnifying glasses or jeweler's loupes (which cost $10-30) to inspect cards more carefully before deciding whether to submit them. Take notes about each card's condition in your own words—this helps you make informed decisions about submission.

A useful rule of thumb: if you're unsure whether a card is worth grading, research its estimated market value first. Cards in poor condition (grades 1-4) are rarely worth the grading cost unless they're extremely rare or historically significant. Most people find that grading cards in condition grades 7 or higher makes financial sense.

Practical takeaway: Examine your collection using the grading scale as reference, research which of your cards actually have market value, and compare your cards' appearance to published grading examples before submitting anything for evaluation.

Preparing Cards for Safe Submission

Once you've decided which cards to submit, proper preparation prevents damage during shipping. The biggest risk to ungraded cards is bending or creasing during transit, so protection matters significantly. Start by placing each card in an individual card sleeve—these thin plastic covers protect against dust and minor handling. Standard card sleeves cost less than a dollar each. For extra protection, many collectors use two sleeves, placing the card in one sleeve and then sliding that sleeve into another sleeve in the opposite direction.

Get Your Free Terro Liquid Ant Baits User Guide →

After sleeving, place the card inside a team bag or penny sleeve combined with a toploader. Toploaders are rigid plastic holders about 2.5 inches by 3.5 inches designed to hold a standard card. The toploader prevents bending during shipping. This combination—card in sleeve inside toploader—is the standard protection method used by serious collectors. Some grading companies provide specific shipping instructions or approved packaging methods, so check their website before mailing your cards.

For shipping, place each protected card in a small cardboard box or padded mailer. Do not use regular envelopes without rigid protection, as standard mail can bend cards easily. Include a packing list that identifies each card by set name, card number, and any special characteristics. This documentation helps the grading company process your submission accurately. Pack the cards so they cannot move around inside the box during transit—use bubble wrap, foam peanuts, or crumpled paper as filler.

Insurance and tracking matter for valuable submissions. Use a shipping service that provides tracking numbers and signature confirmation, especially for cards worth $50 or more. Keep photos of your cards before shipping and copies of your packing list for your records. Consider using registered mail or insured shipping options offered by USPS, UPS, or FedEx. Some grading companies offer mail-in submission forms that include insurance options.

Practical takeaway: Use card sleeves, team bags, and toploaders for protection; pack securely in a padded box; use tracked shipping with insurance; and keep documentation of what you're sending.

Understanding Grading Company Services and Costs

Different grading companies offer various service levels that affect both cost and turnaround time. PSA, the largest Pokémon card grader, offers multiple tiers. Standard service typically takes 30-40 business days but costs less per card. Expedited services take 7-15 business days and cost more. Priority or rush services complete grading in 1-7 business days at the highest price point. For a standard $20 base card, standard service might cost $10, while expedited could be $20-30, and rush service could exceed $50. Rare or particularly valuable cards justify faster turnaround times because market prices can change.

Free Guide to Filing a Restraining Order Process →

Beckett Grading Services and CGC Cards offer similar tiered structures with comparable pricing. Beckett is known for detailed subgrades that break down centering, corners, edges, and surface quality separately, while PSA provides an overall grade. CGC Cards has gained market share in recent years and emphasizes rigorous grading standards. The choice between companies sometimes depends on regional availability, personal preference, or specific card type. Many collectors submit the same card to different companies to compare results, though this approach increases costs.

Additional costs beyond basic grading include authentication (verifying a card is genuine, not counterfeit), special holders or slabs for display, and potentially recertification if a card's grade is disputed. Shipping both to and from the grading company is your responsibility unless they offer prepaid return labels. Some companies charge extra for return shipping or provide included return shipping only with certain service levels. Factor these costs into your decision about which cards to grade.

Volume discounts may be available if you submit multiple cards at once. Some graders offer reduced per-card rates for submissions of 10, 25, or 50+ cards. Membership programs exist for frequent submitters; annual membership in PSA's collector program, for example, can reduce per-card grading costs if you submit cards regularly. Understanding the full cost structure helps you budget realistically for your grading project.

Practical takeaway: Research pricing for all service tiers at your chosen grading company, calculate total costs including shipping, and consider volume discounts or membership programs if you plan to grade multiple cards.

The Grading Process and